Different Types of a Collar for Dogs and When to Use Each One
Check out our training collar setup, d-ring dog collar, easy dog collars, and more!]
Walking into a pet store or browsing online can feel overwhelming when you’re faced with dozens of different straps, chains, and buckles. Choosing the right collar isn't just about picking a fun color—it's about safety, control, and communication.
The right tool depends entirely on what you are doing. Are you going for a casual sniff-walk, training a powerful puller, or hiking through muddy trails? Using the wrong type of collar can actually mask training issues or, worse, cause physical injury to your dog's neck or trachea.
Here is a breakdown of the most common types of collars and when to use each one so you can make the best choice for your dog.
Standard Collars for Everyday Use
For most dogs, these are the "daily drivers"—the tools you use for ID tags, quick potty breaks, and standard walks.
The Flat Collar
Description: The traditional collar with a buckle or snap, available in materials like nylon, leather, or coated webbing.
When to Use: Everyday use. This is the best option for holding ID tags and attaching a leash for dogs with good manners.
While nylon is common, it absorbs water and traps bacteria, leading to that dreaded "wet dog" smell. Leather is classic but high-maintenance. For active dogs, a weatherproof, coated strap (like those from Hoss Straps) is often the superior choice. It provides the strength of a heavy-duty flat collar but is completely impervious to water and odors, making it a "set it and forget it" solution for daily wear.
The Breakaway Collar
Description: A collar with a specialized safety buckle designed to release (undo) automatically if pressure is applied.
When to Use: Safety during unsupervised time. These are critical for multi-dog households where dogs wrestle, or for dogs left in crates or kennels. The mechanism prevents strangulation if the collar gets snagged on a fence, branch, or another dog's jaw.
Note: Never attach a leash to a breakaway collar without a secondary safety backup, as it will pop open if your dog pulls.
The GPS Collar
Description: A smart collar (or an attachment for a flat collar) that provides location tracking and sometimes health metrics like activity levels or sleep quality.
When to Use: Safety and health monitoring. These are essential for owners of "flight risk" dogs or those who live on large properties. Modern GPS collars can even alert you if your dog leaves a designated safe zone, offering peace of mind that a standard tag cannot match.
Specialized Tools for Safety and Control
Some dogs have physical builds or behavioral needs that make standard collars unsafe or ineffective. These tools offer specific solutions for those scenarios.
The Martingale Collar
Description: Features a secondary loop that tightens slightly when the dog pulls. Unlike a choke chain, it has a limit to how tight it can get, preventing it from fully closing off the airway.
When to Use: Preventing escape. These are virtually mandatory for sighthounds (like Greyhounds or Whippets) whose heads are narrower than their necks, allowing them to slip backward out of regular flat collars. They provide security without the choking effect of a slip lead.
The Head Collar (Head Halter)
Description: A strap that loops around the dog's nose and behind the ears, similar to a horse's halter. It controls the dog's head direction.
When to Use: Leash pulling. This is often described as "power steering" for dogs. If you control the head, the body follows. It is highly effective for owners who physically struggle to hold a strong dog, as it redirects the dog's forward momentum into a turn without putting pressure on the trachea.
The Harness (Collar Alternative)
Description: A body restraint that distributes pressure across the chest and back rather than the neck.
When to Use: Pulling and breathing issues. Harnesses are the recommended choice for brachycephalic (flat-faced) breeds like Pugs or French Bulldogs, who are prone to airway collapse if pressure is placed on their throats. They are also ideal for hiking or long-line tracking where the dog needs freedom to move without neck strain.
Advanced Training Collars
These collars are designed for active training and behavior modification. They should generally be viewed as temporary teaching tools rather than permanent "walking gear."
The Slip Collar (Training Collar)
Description: A simple loop of chain or rope that tightens without limit as the dog pulls.
When to Use: Training contexts only. These are used to deliver quick corrections for leash pulling or focus. However, because they can tighten indefinitely, they pose a safety risk if left on an unsupervised dog or used by an inexperienced handler. They should never be used on puppies.
The Prong Collar
Description: A metal chain with blunt prongs that pinch the skin evenly around the neck when tension is applied.
When to Use: Training (with extreme caution). While some trainers use these for communication with large, stubborn dogs, they are controversial. Veterinary professionals largely discourage them due to the risk of physical and emotional damage if used incorrectly. If you choose to use one, do so only under the direct supervision of a professional trainer.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is a harness better than a collar for a puppy?
Yes, for walking purposes. Puppies have fragile necks and haven't learned loose-leash manners yet. A harness protects their throat from injury while they learn, though you should still use a lightweight flat collar for holding their ID tags.
2. Can I leave a martingale collar on my dog all the time?
Generally, no. Because the extra loop can hang loose when not under tension, it poses a higher risk of getting snagged on furniture or crates than a standard flat collar. It is best used strictly for walks.
3. What is the most durable material for a dog collar?
Coated webbing (often called Biothane or similar) is widely considered the most durable. Unlike nylon which frays, or leather which cracks with water exposure, coated straps are waterproof, freeze-proof, and easy to clean, making them ideal for active outdoor dogs.
4. How tight should a dog collar be?
You should be able to comfortably slide two fingers flat between the collar and your dog's neck. If you can fit more, it is a safety risk (slipping out); if you can fit fewer, it may be restricting their breathing or causing skin irritation.
5. Why does my dog's collar smell so bad?
Fabric collars like nylon absorb oils from your dog's skin, dirt, and water, creating a breeding ground for bacteria. To fix this, you can wash the collar regularly or switch to a non-porous material like a coated strap that can be wiped clean instantly.
